The Current Outlook - The Collector's Golden Age?

The book trade--including collectors, dealers, librarians and the book-scouts (what few are left)--has changed radically since the introduction of the internet and the large search services over the last ten years.

We've been around the book trade for over 50 years now. We started as collectors in the 1950s, issued a few catalogs every year in the 1960s and early 1970s (under the name Allen Ahearn-First Editions), and opened the Quill & Brush as a book and art store in 1976.

Initially, our goal was not to make money but to support our own collection by selling duplicates or books we found on scouting expeditions. We achieved this goal -- at least the part about not making any money.

Over the years that we've been associated with the book trade, it has gone through many changes. Gone are the great stocking-of-the-libraries days of the 1950s and 1960s when, we are told, a bookseller could go to huge bookstores in major cities with a wants lists from libraries and spend days accumulating books on the list, then go back to shop or home, mark them up, mail them to the institution, and go look for more.

By the 1970s, when we became more involved in the trade, not only were the great stocking-of-the-libraries days over but most of the large stores were gone. Locally, Lowdermilks in Washington closed at the end of the 1960s, and there was no successor. In most cases smaller shops moved into the area, but there was no longer a large central establishment. At present there are large bookstores, but except for those who own their buildings, such as the Strand in New York City, most are located outside the large cities. The reason being that the rents in the cities or even in the close-in suburbs are unreasonable for large spaces.

In those days, and up until 1998 or so, catalogs were the primary means of selling to a far-flung clientele. Book fairs, which are a good way for booksellers to meet new collectors, existed, but the number per year were relatively small. During the 1970s and 1980s the number of fairs increased, so, by century's end, we had gone from perhaps a few fairs a year to a few a week. Now, we see many of these fairs disappearing again as most of the smaller and part time dealers have the ability to reach a world market instantaneously over the net.

Over the past three decades, the book trade was slowly evolving, but nothing could have prepared us for the changes in the last ten years. The Internet has drastically and irrevocably changed the way we sell books and the way collectors and others book purchasers buy their books. Although the Internet has been around awhile (we have been on it with a home page since 1995), it was only in 1998/9 that the number of books on line increased dramatically. Books that previously may have taken years to track down could be located in an instant using the Internet. At the beginning of 1998, Advance Book Exchange (ABE) had 1,500 "dealers" or subscribers on line, listing a cumulative total of approximately 4,000,000 out-of-print books. By the middle of 1999, the numbers were up to 4,500 and 12,000,000, respectively. Now, we believe, they advertise 13,500 subscribers with about 110,000,000 books.

There is no doubt that the availability of so many books has reduced the prices of common books. In the far off past (1997), a collector's or dealer's book buying universe was defined by the catalogs received, the stocks in the local stores, and books seen in bookstores on visits to other towns or cities. Now, one can see almost the total availability of titles world-wide, as so many books are on the net.

Book prices are set by supply and demand. If the supply goes up drastically, as it has, demand is sated and prices go down. So, if there are 200 copies in fine condition of a certain first edition, the prices of these books will be priced less than comparable copies 10 years ago.

Golden Opportunity

Of course, this represents a golden opportunity for the collector to buy collectible copies by the authors they like at a reasonable price. We know that there are so many copies of certain titles that it will be years before the prices go up. But we have also noticed that where there were 20 or 30 collectible copies of a title five years ago, now there may be two or three. There may be 20 copies on-line, but 18 will be reprints, ex-library or beat up copies without dust jackets. The other day we were looking for a Patrick O'Brian English first edition. Nice copies were in the $500 to $600 range. There were six copies on the net. None of them were in America. Three were in the UK, two in Australia, one in New Zealand. We're sure that if we had looked a few years ago we would have found many more copies available.

Nick Basbanes, in his book A Gentle Madness, called the late 19th Century and early Twentieth Century the Golden Age of book collecting, 60 years when the building of great libraries became an emblem of wisdom and accomplishment. We think that the current period will be looked back on in 10 years or so as the Golden Age when supply pushed the prices of collectible books down and smart buyers took advantage of this to build good collections.

Of course, on the other hand, the net has shown that many books we had thought were relatively common were actually uncommon. The nice copies of these books were bought up during the first few years they were listed on the net. Now, because there are few if any copies for sale, the prices for nice copies of these books are far above the prices for comparable copies five or so years ago.

We have compiled price guides for first books from 1975 through 2000, and the more general Collected Books from 1991 to 2002. We noted a marked increase in prices and interest starting in 1987, after the stock market downturn - the opposite of the 1929 reaction. We'll leave it to others to explain why, but the prices of first books, which include many high spots (books considered classics or rarities), started increasing dramatically. Perhaps 25 to 50 percent a year in 1988. We had done guides in 1978 and 1983 and saw a normal inflation adjustment during this period. But, in the 1986 edition we noted that prices were just about flat from 1983 to 1986, with very few exceptions. During 1986 and 1987 the market stayed flat, but in 1988 prices for high spots started escalating. It's not that other prices didn't go up too, just not at the same rate. Our estimates for a fine copy of the first edition of Salinger's Catcher in the Rye in the dustwrapper was $100 in 1978, $500 in 1986 and $7,500 in 2000, and $15,000 or more now; Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird was $50 in 1978, $250 in 1986, and $7,500 in 2000, and $15,000 or more now.


The only thing we know for sure is that for fifty years we've been told that the first edition market will never hold up, and for almost that long we've been told that many of our books were priced too high. Can you imagine someone asking $100 for a first of The Catcher in the Rye! In fact, we know the first statement has not turned out to be true, as the first edition marketplace continues to be active. As for the second comment, our prices could be a little ahead of the time, but as a fellow dealer said at a fair recently when asked if a certain book he had in his booth was really worth $2,500, "Not yet."

We in the modern first trade have a sense that the general antiquarian dealers don't feel we're real antiquarians. We're a little sensitive about this. We ourselves thought we understood the term, and when asked to define the difference between an antiquarian book and a modern first edition we always used the example of a Churchill first edition, perhaps My Early Life published in 1930. If it is a very nice copy in the original cloth in a fine dustwrapper it would be considered a modern first edition, but if the dustwrapper was missing and the book was pretty beat up, or if the covers were gone and it was bound in full leather, we understood it to be an antiquarian book.

We understand eighteenth-century-and-earlier books as being antiquarian and assume if we sell a Dickens, Melville, or Twain that maybe we are dabbling in the antiquarian world. But what of a Jack London first, particularly in a dustwrapper? It's quite old, a hundred years now. Is it an antiquarian book, or is to be forever a modern first edition? Are Hemingway, Faulkner, Fitzgerald, and Steinbeck forever to be "modern"? They've lasted as "modern" throughout the last 100 years. Will they be able to hold on to the title throughout all of the twenty-first Century? And what of more recent books, published in the last few decades of the twentieth century? Because they were published in the last century, are they all a century old now?

Well, somehow we will continue, the buyers and sellers. But the collector should try to buy the best copy available and either buy signed or inscribed copies or go to a book signing and get the author to sign your books, because the signed copies, even of common books will always hold their value better than unsigned copies.

Good luck and good books to you.